A chilly morning today, which I began with an invigorating run along the Ouse, a dull gunmetal grey in the early light. Later in the day, the spring sunshine is back, and I'm enjoying the birdsong in the back garden as I try to make sense of the illness from which I'm now recovering.
As well as taking us over, wiping us out and shutting us down, depression is also believed by many - certainly by the experts I have most faith in - to be a kind of defence mechanism for the body. It is an extreme reaction by the body to say 'enough!... enough of pushing me to the limit; enough of stubbornly ignoring me; enough of the wilful damage you are inflicting on me'. The body (and its raw emotions and feelings) always tells the truth, but the mind is a consummate liar... a bullshitter
par excellence, a cunning manipulator of the first degree. This is particularly true of the depressive's mind, which has been acting out complex roles and weaving a well-meaning web of subterfuge for the better part of a lifetime.
The body, when it has cried
'basta!', cuts most of its ties with the mind, and goes into a form of hibernation. It must protect itself, and its survival instinct comes to the fore. The 'fight or flight' impulses which produced such a deluge of stress hormones were the forerunner to this act of surrender, when the body gives itself over willingly to the fate which awaits it.
The mind is slower to react, but react it must. Without the body as an ally, it sulks and wails, bemoaning the hopelessness of the situation until it, too, sooner or later, comes to apprehend the gravity of the situation. It closes most of its circuits down, effectively retreating into standby mode while its inner workings begin to recover and find new connections. This process takes time - indeed it
must take time, as it is vital that these new connections are found.
So if depression can be seen as a defence, what is it defending us against? Well, in my case, I believe it was shielding me from what I dread most - a loss of control. Having always felt the need to work hard (or
'try harder') to succeed, this need for control is deeply ingrained in my being, and has the power to set off a painful and destructive cycle when I sense that it might not be met. In my efforts to retain control and do everything well (there's also an undeniable streak of perfectionism here), I often flail against the current while punishing myself for not making more progress. Trying hard equates to suffering, but it also equates to 'being good', because this is what won me the approval of those I loved most when I was small (and not so small!).
If I were to give up this need for control, the logic goes, I might not suffer. However, I would also not be 'trying hard'. Worse, this would risk failure and letting others down, so would clearly be 'bad'. Therefore it is some kind of warped pride which compels me to try harder and which lodges this 'fear of failure' deep in my psyche. At a deeper level, it is a child's fear of being rejected or abandoned by his mum. Therefore the prospect of not trying hard is too terrible to contemplate.
As Dorothy Rowe says in her excellent book,
Depression: The Way Out of Your Prison, the illness is a defence against chaos and the terrifying prospect that you will crumble and disappear. It is 'the fear that the universe is falling apart around me and all that ever existed will disappear... the greatest fear of all'. We feel this fear, she argues, when we discover that there is a serious discrepancy between what we thought our life was and what it
actually is. The answer lies in recognising the
truth of our situation and in letting go of the need for control, which was only ever illusory in its nature. We come to realise that we are not in control of life's events and, what's more, we never have been. But we
can control how we
interpret what happens to us, and it is in changing this
interpretation that we begin to see choices, possibilities and - ultimately - the way forward.
As for my
own misinterpretation, perhaps I always saw my life as a pursuit of all the traditional trappings of ‘success’, obtainable only through trying hard and ‘being good’ (commendable impulses in a well-behaved 'achiever' who was seen as the
golden boy of the family). The creative impulse (in my case, dreamlike escapism and the urge to write) began to feel like a frustration - or a curse, even; certainly a distraction with the power to tempt me away from what I felt I ‘ought’ to be doing - namely getting on with the business of succeeding in life. Therefore this creative impulse or 'passion' was something be suppressed, just like those early childhood emotions which weren't gaining the approval I craved.
Now, of course, I finally see that our passions are our blessings, and the potential source of all our life-affirming inspiration. This creativity isn't something I need to search for; it’s already here
within me, if only I will let it emerge, grow and flourish.
This is how I've come to realise that depression is a journey into our own authenticity, and it's only cure is the truth.